Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Don't miss
Home / Verdicts & Settlements / Families settle over fatal helicopter crash

Families settle over fatal helicopter crash

NTSB blamed pilot error for accident that killed four

The families of two people killed in a medical helicopter crash in Clay County reached an $8 million settlement with the aircraft’s operator.

The Aug. 26, 2011, crash near the town of Mosby killed pilot James Freudenberg, flight nurse Randy Bever and paramedic Chris Frakes, as well as the patient they were transporting, Terry Tacoronte.

According to a report from the National Transportation Safety Board, the helicopter was transporting a patient from Bethany to Liberty when it ran out of fuel. The pilot realized after takeoff that he had far less fuel than he thought he did and unsuccessfully tried to reach the airport in Mosby to refuel.

The NTSB blamed the crash on pilot error, concluding that Freudenberg had been distracted by several text messages that he sent and received during the flight, and that he was fatigued after being on duty for more than 12 hours.

Relatives of Bever and Tacoronte filed separate wrongful death lawsuits against Englewood, Colo.-based Air Methods Corp., alleging that the company had inadequate policies and oversight procedures regarding minimum fuel reserves.

The parties reached a settlement late last year, which Judge Shane T. Alexander approved in early February. The agreement allocates a total of $5 million to Bever’s widow, Shanna Bever; his children, Justin R. Bever and Taylor Hurt; and his mother, Marilyn Weir. Tacoronte’s husband, Victor E. Tacoronte; and her children Heather Beard, Joshua Taylor and Carrie Homan, shared $3 million.

Attorneys for Air Methods did not return calls seeking comment.

An attorney for the families, Anita Porte Robb, credited Air Methods for taking responsibility for the crash. She said that, in the wake of the crash, the company had pledged to strengthen its policies about texting while flying.



Venue:Clay County Circuit Court
Judge: Shane T. Alexander
Case Numbers/Date: 11CY-CV10505 and 11CY-CV10179/Feb. 5, 2013
Caption: Justin R. Bever, Taylor Hurt, Shanna Bever and Marilyn Weir v. Air Methods Corp.; Victor E. Tacoronte, Heather Beard, Joshua Taylor and Carrie Homan v. Air Methods Corp.
Plaintiffs’ Experts: Richard McSwain, Pensacola, Fla. (metallurgist); Lee Coffman, Amarillo, Texas (aircraft maintenance); Jack Lipscomb, Huddleston, Va. (aircraft accident reconstruction) Don Sommer, Broomfield, Colo. (Engineering); John Ward, Prairie Village, Kan. (economics)
Defendant’s Experts: None
Insurance Carrier: Allianz Global Risks
Plaintiffs’ Attorneys: Anita P. Robb and Gary C. Robb, Robb & Robb, Kansas City; Creath S. Thorne, Creath S. Thorne PC, St. Joseph (for Bever plaintiffs); John M. Spencer and Stephen W. Holaday, Tieman, Spencer, Hook & Hicks, St. Joseph (for Bever plaintiffs); Kirk Presley, Presley & Presley, Kansas City (Tacoronte plaintiffs)
Defendant’s Attorneys: William J. Katt, Wilson Elser, Milwaukee, Wis.; Joe Roper, Foland, Wickens, Eisfelder, Roper & Hofer, Kansas City