Mary Gebhart
Staff Report//July 11, 2025//

Mickes O’Toole, St. Louis
With strong typing skills and attention to detail, Gebhart found her niche in legal support early on. Now a legal administrative assistant at Mickes O’Toole, she’s known for her multitasking skills and navigation of multiple cases each day.
“I just fell into (a career in the legal field),” she says.
What do you enjoy the most about your job?
I like the variation that I get in a lot of my work each day. Some days it’s the same old same old, but most days there is plenty to keep me engaged. No case is the same as the previous one. I am challenged with each new task that I get. I also work with a great group of people who see my skills and understand what that brings to their practice.
What do you consider your biggest professional accomplishment and why?
I think my biggest accomplishment is my being able to multitask and navigate through several different projects in a day.
Sam Kueny
Kueny joined Levy Craig as chief operating officer in March 2020, just as the pandemic shifted workplaces across the country.
Lauren Edghill
Lauren Edghill began working for Mickes O’Toole as a paralegal during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Jennifer Meyer
Jennifer Meyer is known across Swanson Martin & Bell as a highly skilled and dependable paralegal.
Kathryn (Katie) O’Flynn
As clinical education program operations manager, O’Flynn merges her interest in law and academia to support students and serve the community.
Shelly Pegg
Shelly Pegg serves as team lead for KCM Team 26, where she mentors legal administrative assistants, supports attorney workflow and helps shape the team’s collaborative culture.
Michelle Baugh
As legal operations and contracts manager at ICL Americas, Michelle Baugh plays an important role in managing the in-house legal team’s daily operations.
Jasmine Barnes
Jasmine Barnes is a paralegal with Cofman Townsley whose exceptional empathy and kindness led her colleagues to nominate her for the Unsung Hero Award.
Andrew Herr
Paralegal Andrew Herr never seeks the spotlight, but he is always present in the Greene County Prosecutor’s Office ensuring that justice is carried out.
Rachel Buchholz
Rachel Buchholz has worked with the attorneys of DLM Law since 2008, balancing dual roles as a paralegal and the firm’s office manager.
Don Borgman
Don Borgman became the business manager of Langdon & Emison after transitioning from a career in commercial banking.
Colleen Hutchins
As Office Administrator for Rooney McBride & Smith, Colleen Hutchins handles a wide range of administrative tasks for the office.
Bianca Rael
Bianca Rael is a receptionist with the Mutrux firm and says she chose to work in the legal field because she always knew she wanted to work somewhere that allowed her to help others.
Sandy Hammer
Sandy Hammer’s outstanding leadership as office administrator led to immediate impact at the Jones Family Law Firm, her nominators say.
Dawn Renwick
Paralegal Dawn Renwick truly is the unsung hero of Haar & Woods. She has been with the firm ever since its founding 28 years ago.
Kim Morgan
Morgan has built a career in legal recruiting that spans decades and hundreds of hires.
Wendi Bridges
Wendi Bridges has been a driving force at Baldwin & Vernon for years, playing a pivotal role in the firm’s most successful cases.
Kelli Strader
Kelli Strader left a large law firm to join Hinrichs & Scott as its sole paralegal at launch — a move that helped define the firm’s structure and identity.
Don Harris
Senior Business Engagement Manager Don Harris is “a dedicated, hardworking individual who goes above and beyond no matter how big or small the project and truly embodies what an unsung legal hero is,” according to his colleagues.
Megan Herbert
Megan Herbert has built a career rooted in client advocacy.
Aimee Orosco
Aimee Orosco is a nurse paralegal who is described by her colleagues as a knowledgeable and diligent worker with excellent writing skills.
Stormy Couchman
Stormy Couchman is the most senior paralegal at Grayson & Grayson, bringing nearly 30 years of legal experience to the firm.
Leigh Inman
Leigh Inman serves as library & information services manager at Sandberg Phoenix, where she is recognized for her expertise in legal research and her forward-thinking approach to technology.
Julie A. Herl
Julie A. Herl serves as paralegal/office manager for Forsgren Fisher McCalmont DeMarea Tysver. She “brings to the job a fierce combination of a strong work ethic and a friendly, approachable personality.”
Sara Ream
Sara Ream didn’t plan to work in law, but the values of the legal profession won her over.
Danielle E. Steiner
As regional office manager for MG+M, Danielle Steiner is responsible for interviewing candidates, mentoring them, and streamlining operations within the firm’s many offices.
Victoria Fisher
Legal assistant Victoria Fisher joined Turney LG in early 2023 and has quickly become an indispensable member of the team.
Marsha Presley
Presley’s career began with an unexpected job posting.
Freida Edwards
Records Specialist Freida Edwards “Not only runs and maintains a very active and organized file center in the St. Louis office,” according to her colleagues, “but also continues to play a leading role in the firm’s ‘Paper-Lite’ project, which aims to reduce out-of-date records by scanning to create digital copies and shredding documents.”
Krista Nance
Krista Nance’s unwavering dedication to the Mutrux Firm’s clients makes her an invaluable team member and compassionate paralegal.
Angie McCrory
Angie works as a regional office administrator with BCLP and first started with the firm in 1997.
John Penberthy
John Penberthy has supported Lathrop GPM’s Private Client Services and Real Estate teams for nearly 20 years, bringing more than 35 years of total legal experience.
Carol Eiskant
Carol Eiskant is a receptionist with Baker Sterchi Cowden & Rice.
Jessica Rogers
Settlement Team Manager Jessica Rogers “is the kind of person whose impact is felt both in measurable outcomes and in the intangibles — like how a client feels heard for the first time, or how a team member feels supported during a stressful week,” her colleagues say.
Linde Bushong
Linde Bushong has spent her career working in office management roles where she’s known for thinking multiple steps ahead and keeping things running smoothly.
Morgan Brummer
A recent graduate of the University of Missouri, legal assistant Morgan Brummer has quickly become a dependable member of the Mutrux team.
Alyse James
Since joining Mutrux Firm in 2023, Alyse James has steadily advanced from intake to case management and now serves as senior case manager.
Jill Sanders
Jill Sanders is the sole paralegal for the Jones Family Law Group — a busy family law practice.
Elaine Freeman
Elaine Freeman has been the quiet force behind the success of Taryn Henry PC for 26 years.
Jay Colon
Litigation Support Supervisor Jay Colon is known for his attention to detail and calm, solutions-focused mindset.
Kristen Weese
Kristen Weese transitioned into legal work from managing a chiropractic office, finding the legal field to be a natural fit.
Rachel Claudius
Paralegal Rachel Claudius is an integral part of the Law Firm of Henry Tanner.
Jami L. Boyles
Chief Administrative Officer for Lewis Rice, Jami L. Boyles, is the embodiment of leadership, integrity, and effectiveness.
Kristie Walker
Kristie Walker began working at Thompson Coburn in 1993 as a legal secretary.
Related Content
Latest Opinion Digests
- Insurance-Interpleader-Competing Claims to Insurance Proceeds
- Employer-Employee-Discrimination-Hostile Work Environment
- Criminal Law-Rape-Oral and Written Judgments
- Torts-Defamation-Official Immunity
- Real Property-Adverse Possession-Oral Agreement for Sale
- Domestic Relations-Termination of Parental Rights-Parental Unfitness
- Criminal Law-Violation of Order of Protection-Scope of Cross-Examination
- Criminal Law-Resisting Arrest-Sufficiency of Evidence
- Criminal Law-Post-Conviction Relief-Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
- Domestic Relations-Dissolution-Property Division
- Criminal Law-Assault-Self-Defense
Top stories
- AAA Insurance faces $21.5M bad faith verdict in Clay County
- Legal Limelight: Meghan S. Largent champions landowners in takings cases
- Supreme Court rejects bright-line rule on FAA worker exemption
- 2026 Unsung Legal Heroes: Publisher’s Letter, honorees
- Driver in accident settles negligence suit with other motorist
- Verdicts may fuel Missouri social media claims
- Judge Anthony Rex Gabbert retiring after 32 years
- Severe motorcycle crash nets seven-figure settlement





