Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Inebriated driver settles with family injured in crash for $1.5M

Alan Scher Zagier//July 31, 2019//

Inebriated driver settles with family injured in crash for $1.5M

Alan Scher Zagier//July 31, 2019//

Listen to this article

A boy severely injured by an inebriated pickup-truck operator settled a suit against the driver and his insurer for a total of $1.35 million.

The settlement was the largest of four connected to the crash on July 17, 2017 in Independence. Altogether, the settlements totaled more than $1.54 million.

Owen Hernandez, who was 9 at the time, was seated in the back of his grandmother’s 2013 Chevrolet Cruze when it was struck by a 2003 Toyota Tundra pickup truck that had hit a median while attempting to turn into a retail parking area on northbound Missouri Route 291 near East Gudgell Avenue, an Independence Police Department report shows.

The Hernandez family car, driven by Gilbert Laughlin, the grandmother’s boyfriend, was coming to a stop while exiting the parking lot. The car was first struck in the rear and then again by an airborne trailer that had become separated from the pickup.

Pickup driver Tad Edward Mitchell, 51, of Independence, told police that he had consumed four beers prior to the crash. He pleaded guilty in April 2018 to a felony count of driving while intoxicated, causing serious bodily injury, online court records show.

Mitchell was sentenced to four years in prison and served 120 days of shock time before his release on a suspended execution of sentence.

Records provided by plaintiff’s attorney Laurie Del Percio show that Owen Hernandez — whose injuries included traumatic brain injury, partial hearing loss in his right ear, multiple facial fractures and displaced-bone forearm fractures of his right radius and ulna — will receive $1.25 million from his family’s Farmers Insurance policy via a 30-year structured settlement starting when he turns 18.

The settlement includes an additional $100,000 from the Hernandez family’s underinsured-motorist policy with GEICO.

Del Percio also represented passengers Tracy Hernandez, who settled her own claim against Mitchell regarding her neck and back injuries for $25,000, as well as Owen’s 4-year-old sister Kylie, who settled for $15,000 with neck and back injuries, and Laughlin, who settled for $4,000 for an abrasion above his eye. Kylie Hernandez’s settlement won court approval in September 2018.

RELATED: Click to search for and submit your Verdicts & Settlements

 MOTOR-VEHICLE COLLISION
Breakdown: For Owen Hernandez: $1,350,000; For Tracy Hernandez: $25,000; For Kylie Hernandez: $15,000; For Gilbert Laughlin: $4,000
Venue: Jackson County Circuit Court at Independence
Case Number/Date: 1916-CV11604/May 23, 2019
Judge: James Kanatzar
Plaintiffs’ Expert: Tracy Wingate, Overland Park, Kansas (life-care planning); Dr. Lori Bovajian-O’Neill, Independence (sports medicine)
Special Damages: $71,458 in paid medical bills
Insurers: Farmers (for Mitchell), GEICO
Caption: Owen Hernandez, by and through his mother and next of friend Tiara Beatty v. Dennis and Tad Mitchell, GEICO General Insurance Co.
Plaintiffs’ Attorney: Laurie Del Percio, The Horn Law Firm, Independence
Defendants’ Attorneys: James Morrow; Morrow Willnauer Church, Kansas City; Amy Hill, Law Offices of Jerry Crowder, Overland Park, Kansas

Latest Opinion Digests

See all digests

Legal Tech

See All Legal Tech News

Top stories

See more news